PDA

View Full Version : America's military faces the most thankless task in the history of warfare.


ethics
10-01-2004, 12:07 AM
An author I truly admire for his ability to think outside the box and question everything had a great article over at WSJ (http://www.opinionjournal.com/extra/?id=110005673) on our Troops.

Specific quote that I would like to draw your attention on is this:

In months of travels with the American military, I have learned that the smaller the American footprint and the less notice it draws from the international media, the more effective is the operation. One good soldier-diplomat in a place like Mongolia can accomplish miracles. A few hundred Green Berets in Colombia and the Philippines can be adequate force multipliers. Ten thousand troops, as in Afghanistan, can tread water. And 130,000, as in Iraq, constitutes a mess that nobody wants to repeat--regardless of one's position on the war....
...

.. "The American military now has the most thankless task of any military in the history of warfare: to provide the security armature for an emerging global civilization that, the more it matures--with its own mass media and governing structures--the less credit and sympathy it will grant to the very troops who have risked and, indeed, given their lives for it."

archidante
10-13-2004, 07:30 PM
amen and amen.

Sierra Mike
10-14-2004, 08:20 AM
Well, Kaplan does overlook some historical merits to the evolution of warfare...as a former cavalryman, I can attest to the introduction of the horse as being the conceptualization of maneuver warfare, which is what the US does extremely well. And I guess he's unaware that for every 12-man Special Forces Operational Detachment (Alpha) that gets fielded, they're backed by two 80-100 men Bravo teams, so the logistics tail isn't as light as he might want to think. And heaven forbid what an aviation unit brings to the party...a Black Hawk battalion can't even deploy in its own aircraft!

Still, the gist of the article rings true to me.

SM

Mobile Phone | Hypnosis | iKobo | Car Loan | Free Myspace Layouts